Literature Review Checklist

Format and references

Is the paper in APA-style?

Are there at least 12-15 references?

Abstract

Is the abstract 100-120 words long?

Is it clear and understandable, with a problem statement, a description of what you will cover, conclusions, and implications?

Does it summarize the paper well?

Introduction

Do the first couple of paragraphs set up the topic well?

Is there an interesting and relevant beginning to draw the reader in?

Is there a preview of the topics to be covered in the paper?

Body (content)

Are the cited studies relevant?

Are they presented appropriately?

Are the studies integrated well?

Is there a sense of analysis, or is the paper just reporting findings?

Is the review deep enough?

Is the right amount of detail used?

Does the reader get a sense of the state of research in the topic area?

Organization

Is the paper well-organized?

Does it use appropriate headings?

Are the studies organized in an understandable way?

Composition

Is the paper well-written?

Are there spelling/grammar mistakes?

Is there excessive use of passive voice or unnecessary words?

Are there awkward sentences?

Is the paper easily understandable?

Is it written for the right audience level?

Conclusions

Is there a summary of the paper near the end?

Are clear conclusions drawn from the reviewed literature?

Are there suggestions for further research and limitations of current knowledge in the area noted?

Are implications of these conclusions discussed?

Do you have a clear take-home message at the end?